Judge Dismisses Injured Man’s Claim agains the City of New York November 5, 2009

After a two-day trial in Brooklyn federal court, a visiting federal judge from Louisiana has dismissed the case of a 66-year old Bronx resident, Joseph Adde, who claimed he was injured in the crash of the Staten Island Ferry Andrew J. Barberi.  

The crash, which occurred on October 15, 2003, caused the death of 11 ferry passengers and resulted in over 170 lawsuits filed against the City of New York for their negligence in breaking their own rule requiring two pilots present in the pilot house. The sole pilot in the pilothouse passed out, causing the ferry to crash into a concrete maintenance pier. Mr. Adde claimed that he suffered a herniated disc in his back when other passengers fell on him during the accident. The City claimed that Mr. Adde wasn’t even on the ferry that day. The back injury ultimately required surgery. At Mr. Adde’s deposition, he testified that after the ferry crashed, he walked to Battery Park from the ferry’s Manhattan Terminal, although the crash happened near the Staten Island Terminal. The City also claimed that Mr. Adde’s back injury was pre-existing. After a two day bench trial, which means that the judge and not a jury decided the case, the court concluded that Mr. Adde’s testimony was “much less than credible.”

The City claimed fraud and Mr. Adde’s attorney claimed that his client is an African immigrant who speaks English as his 4th language. The City will vigorously defend lawsuits that they believe are fraudulent and refused to settle the case before trial. However, the claimant will most likely appeal the judge’s ruling in the hopes of getting a new trial, so i am sure that we have not heard the last about it.

Frank Dito is a New York Personal Injury attorney specializing in New York real estate law , New York business law, and New York franchise law. You can visit his Law Firm Decker, Decker, Dito and Internicola website by clicking here, download his FREE New York Car Insurance book, or call him at 718-979-4300 or 1-800-310-5520 for a free case analysis.

Post Footer automatically generated by Add Post Footer Plugin for wordpress.